How to Make Soft Peanut Butter Cookies

Compare Products

Choose upto 5 items for side by side feature comparison

Wishlist

Go to collections

Show filters

Shop How to Make Soft Peanut Butter Cookies

Sponsored

David's Cookies Butter Pecan Melt…

Homemade Soft Peanut Butter Co…

$60.00

Etsy

Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies…

No-Bake Coconut Pecan Praline Co…

Poochie Butter Peanut Butter Sof…

$7.19

$7.99

Chewy.com

Buttery Pecan Snowball Cookie…

Old Fashioned Homemade Pean…

$21.85

Etsy

Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip C…

$5.00

Nurtured 9 Store

Curbside

Pillsbury Soft Baked Mini Chocolate C…

David's Cookies 5Lb Assorted Cookies …

Downloadable Reese's Peanut B…

Peanut Butter Chip Cookies By Mildre…

$26.95

Vermont Country …

Raw Red Skin Peanuts (Uncook…

Madegood Soft Baked Chocolate …

Mini Peanut Butter Cups - 4 Pound B…

Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies …

$65.00

Etsy

4.5

Bite Size Chocolate Peanut Butter No …

Skout Organic Soft Baked Cookies P…

$6.19

$6.49

Vitacost

Betty Crocker Gluten Free Choc…

Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies …

$65.00

Etsy

4.5

Bite Size Chocolate Peanut Butter No …

Peanut Butter Blossoms

$29.95

Etsy

5.0

Gourmet Cookie Butter Stuffed Co…

$3.50

Etsy

5.0

Fluffernutter Peanut Butter Cookie Rec…

$4.00

Etsy

5.0

Mini Peanut Butter Cups - 4 Pound B…

Skout Organic Soft Baked Cookies P…

$6.19

$6.49

Vitacost

Betty Crocker Gluten Free Choc…

Peanut Butter Meltaways

Incredible Spreadables® Wit…

Stauffer Cookie Ginger Snap, Orig…

White Buttercream Icing

$4.99

Hobby Lobby

Betty Crocker Limited Edition So…

German Pfeffernusse Coo…

$24.90

Vermont Country …

Showing 1 - 36 out of 166 results for "how to make soft peanut butter cookies"
Sort by:
Featured
Featured
Price - High To Low
Price - Low To High
1. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies
  $20.00
  Lil Mamas Sweets And Treats
2. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Texas Sized Peanut Butter Cookies …
  $39.95
  G
  Goldbelly
3. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies
  $3.75
  Country Cakes & Bakes
4. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Cookies
  $1.29
  A
  Amazon.com
5. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Soft Baked Peanut Butter Chocolat…
  $9.00
  Living with Ivey
6. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Bakery Fresh Peanut Butter Cookies
  $3.99
  K
  Kroger
7. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cooki…
  $5.79
  A
  Amazon.com
8. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies
  $7.99
  A
  Atkins Online Store
9. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Gourmet Peanut Butter Cookies (12)
  $29.99
  C
  Cookies by Design USA
10. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Cookies - Peanut Butter Shipping
  $24.99
  L
  Linda's Kitchen
11. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Filled Cookies
  $2.89
  P
  Pronto Home Delivery
12. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Generic Matt'.S Cookies - Cookies …
  $53.99
  A
  Amazon.com
13. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies - 16 Pack
  $15.95
  G
  Goldbelly
14. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies
  $7.95
  W
  Wholesale Unlimited Inc.
15. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookies
  $2.65
  M
  Maven Meals
16. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies - …
  $1.49
  N
  Npcretro
17. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  SALE
  3.9
  ·
  90
  3.9
  90 ratings
  Betty Crocker Peanut Butter Cookie …
  $11.49
  $19.99
  T
  The Retail Market
  Free shipping
18. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
  $9.00
  Zac's Sweet Shop
19. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  3.9
  ·
  90
  3.9
  90 ratings
  Betty Crocker Peanut Butter Cookie …
  $4.42
  W
  Walmart
20. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  2.8
  ·
  18
  2.8
  18 ratings
  Nabisco Nutter Butter Cookie Bites …
  $19.49
  W
  WebstaurantStore
21. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buc-Ees Fresh Baked Peanut Butte…
  $24.95
  J
  Johnny's Goods
22. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  HOMEMADE COOKIE RECIPES, P…
  $9.99
  A
  Amazon.com
23. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  5
  ·
  3
  5
  3 ratings
  Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, …
  $21.70
  A
  Amazon.com
24. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Gourmet Cookies | G…
  $29.99
  C
  Cookies by Design USA
25. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Weis In Store Baked, Home-Style P…
  $3.44
  A
  Amazon.com
26. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  4.8
  ·
  51
  4.8
  51 ratings
  Chocolate, Peanut Butter No Bake …
  $15.00
  Etsy
27. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Bliss Cookies By Gra…
  $18.00
  Fresh Finds Market
28. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  3.8
  ·
  49
  3.8
  49 ratings
  Homestyle Peanut Butter Cookies, 2…
  $90.83
  Industrial Formulators
29. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookie Mix, Makes T…
  $4.98
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
30. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cooki…
  $7.99
  HaloFansGear
  Free shipping
31. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  3.8
  ·
  49
  3.8
  49 ratings
  Homestyle Peanut Butter Cookies, 2…
  $89.01
  AllMyOfficeSupplies.com
  Free shipping
32. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Peanut Butter Cookie Full Size, Doz…
  $18.00
  B
  Billy's Bakery
33. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  SALE
  3.9
  ·
  90
  3.9
  90 ratings
  Betty Crocker 17.5 Oz Peanut Butte…
  $3.99
  $4.99
  B
  Blain's Farm & Fleet
34. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Cooki…
  $49.95
  G
  Goldbelly
35. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Special Offer
  Peak Refuel Peanut Butter Chocolat…
  $7.99
  S
  Sportsman's Warehouse
36. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  SALE
  Peanut Butter Cookies - 16Oz - Mar…
  $1.89
  $1.97
  C
  cartnear
  Free shipping
Oops! We are sorry, something went wrong.
Continue your shopping by clicking on another product
Product added to your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Product removed from your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Product is added to compare already. Please refresh the page.
Product is not found in compare. Please refresh the page.
5 Products already added. Please delete existing selection to add this.
Sponsored
✕
Learn how your ads are chosen
etsy.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Etsy, Inc.
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
amazon.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Amazon.com Services, Inc
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
williams-sonoma.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Williams-Sonoma, Inc.- Pottery Barn
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
hobbylobby.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc.
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
www.ebay.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Vertical Markets GmbH
Location: Germany
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
printerval.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
The gender you selected in your Microsoft account and your search history
The birthdate you shared in your Microsoft account and your search history
Advertiser Details
Name: INMOBI PTE. LTD
Location: Singapore
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
nutstoyou.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Nuts To You
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
kickstosole.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Inmobi Pte Ltd
Location: Singapore
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
walmart.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Wal-Mart Dotcom GNFR
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
chewy.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
The gender you selected in your Microsoft account and your search history
The birthdate you shared in your Microsoft account and your search history
Advertiser Details
Name: Chewy INC
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
davidscookies.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: David's Cookies Inc
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
zazzle.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Zazzle Inc.
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
yamaguo.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Inmobi Pte Ltd
Location: Singapore
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
Ad settings
Peanut Butter Blossoms
$14.25

$15.00
Etsy
5.0
·
198
Peanut Butter Pie "Holly-O's
$35.00
Etsy
Old Fashioned Crunchy Peanut S…
$26.71
$1.67 / 1 oz
Amazon.com
Vienna Cookie Company Heart Li…
$49.95
Williams Sonoma
Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Aka Kola…
$29.59
Etsy
5.0
·
1K+
Peanut Butter Kisses
$25.00
Etsy
5.0
·
65
Affordable · Aromatic · Delicious · Premium Quality · Vibrant Color
Butter Vanilla Bakery Emulsion
$5.49
Hobby Lobby
4.5
·
10K+
Used
Rosy The First Party That Nut ' Se Mi N…
$2.33
eBay.com
I Want Peanutss Butter Not Your O…
$18.95

$22.95
Printerval.com
Peanut Crunch (Squares), 1 Lb.
$8.79
Nuts to You - Bin…
Hearthsong Wooden Gingerbr…
$24.99
Kicktosole
Nutter Butter Cookie Patties Mmf7 Pea…
$11.00

$16.23
Walmart
Vetnique Labs Glandex Dog Ana…
$9.99
Chewy.com
4.5
·
1K+
Sunbutter Natural Nut Bttr Sunflwr C…
$23.40
$7.80 / 1 ct
Amazon.com
3.5
·
8
Gourmet Pistachio Stuffed Cookie Re…
$3.50
Etsy
5.0
·
3
David's Gluten Free Chocolate Chip C…
$29.95
David's Cookies
Baked Goods Peanut Butter Co…
$8.55
Zazzle
Cheryl's Cookies® Bulk Cookie Gift B…
$134.99
$1.35 / 1 ct
Amazon.com
4.5
·
10
Bambino Peanut Butter Flavored
$3.50
Yamaguo
Free shipping
Affordable · Betty Crocker · Delicious · Delightful Texture · Premium Quality
Betty Crocker Delights Suprem…
$2.97
Walmart
4.5
·
1K+
- Best Peanut Butter Cookies | Homemade Cookie Recipe
  https://www.mccormick.com › Recipes › Cookie
  SponsoredIndulge In The Flavors Of Creamy Peanut Butter & Cinnamon With Our Peanut Butter Cookies. Make Delicious Cookies With Just A Few Basic Ingredients! Try Today.
  Quality Ingredients · Non-GMO · Quick & Easy Recipes · No Artificial Flavors
  Types: Recipes, Products, Articles, Guides
  41 S High St Ste 1700, Columbus · 0.3 mi · (614) 294-2545
- easy peanut butter cookie recipes | Official Kindle Store
  https://www.amazon.com › kindle-store › books
  SponsoredFind easy peanut butter cookie recipes in Nonfiction Books on Amazon.
  Explore Amazon Devices · Deals of the Day · Shop Cyber Monday · Shop Best Sellers
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5

Show Only

Brand

Price

Seller

Shop How to Make Soft Peanut Butter Cookies

Best Peanut Butter Cookies | Homemade Cookie Recipe

easy peanut butter cookie recipes | Official Kindle Store